Fixing Affordability: Political Tailwinds, Market Headwinds and an Angry Lame Duck

by Bruce Katz · November 20, 2026

Newsletter

Two weeks after the historic midterm elections, pundits are still trying to sort out what just happened and what it means.  The Financial Times’[1] summary is as good as it gets:

Democratic candidates made affordability and wealth inequality a main part of their platforms to contrast with surging fuel prices and inflation wrought by Trump’s tariffs and the Iran War.

The Democrats’ focus on affordability paid off, with the party winning 51 percent of the vote among the two fifths of voters who said the economy was the most important issue. The one-third of voters who said the state of democracy was the most important issue was also heavily Democrat.

In a stunning reversal from Trump’s win in 2024, the Democratic Party managed to attract more support from poorer voters.

Just two years ago, the Democrats fared much better among the richest third than the poorest, for the first time in decades. In that election, the income group with the largest swing to Democrats was earners who made more than $100,000 a year.

This time, Democrats saw the largest swings in their favor from poorer voters, including those with a total family income of less than $30,000 a year.

As always, the preponderance of national media has focused on the U.S. Congress, where Democrats have gained large majorities in both the House and Senate.

But the mid-term elections were a federalist victory for the Democrats. Democrats now control 30 Governorships, including governors’ offices in 9 of the 10 largest states, representing 75 percent of the population. Moreover, they have scored a trifecta in 22 states, with control of Governorships as well as both state legislative bodies. These trifectas represent 50% of the population and five of the seven likely swing states in the 2028 presidential election.

The largest cities, of course, have historically been a Democratic stronghold. According to Ballotpedia, the partisan breakdown of the 100 largest cities is 67 Democrats, 21 Republicans, one Libertarian, three independents, six nonpartisans, one unaffiliated and one unknown.[2]

Now comes the hard questions. What federalist reforms and initiatives will make a discernible difference in the affordability crisis? And what reforms and initiatives can move forward, given a series of market and fiscal headwinds that are structural in nature and the reality of a divided federal government and a lame duck president who is angry and vindictive?

I’ll take a stab at answering these questions by using housing as a test case. Why housing? Four reasons.

First, housing is the largest expenditure for most households and has been whipsawed by rising interest rates and rising inflation (which boosts the cost of construction and repair).

Second, as I’ve recently written with Sarah Karlinsky, responsibility for housing is federated, divided across different levels of government and sectors of society. That means that states and localities can get stuff done by themselves, even without federal engagement

Third, policy movement on housing is not exclusively dependent on increased appropriations; for example, the federal capital platform for housing production and preservation relies on low-cost debt products, tax incentives and other credit interventions.

Finally, housing has, almost unique amongst domestic policies, found traction in both political parties. The National Housing Crisis Task Force, which I helped found, is a bipartisan effort co-chaired by Utah Governor Spencer Cox, Atlanta Mayor Andre Dickens, Cleveland Mayor Justin Bibb and Fifth Third Bank’s Susan Thomas. The Task Force has codified the most promising state and local solutions and advanced sensible and actionable federal reforms.

With federalist control, the political tailwinds for housing change are substantial and the imperative to show progress at all layers of government is overwhelming.

The good news is that there is much to build upon.

Earlier this year, Congress enacted a bipartisan (albeit modest) 21st Century ROAD to Housing Act, advancing federal support for streamlining zoning, permitting and environmental reviews to build and repair homes faster.

More significantly, states and localities have been stepping up their actions to boost housing production and alleviate their housing shortages. With federal action uncertain, states and localities began experimenting with housing reforms in the mid-2010s. Focusing first on responsibilities firmly within their control (e.g., land use, permitting), state and local governments then gradually expanded into roles (e.g., capital, construction and technology innovation) historically left to the federal government. State and local governments, along with private and civic partners, also began to experiment with substantial governance reforms.

Now comes the reality check.

The imperative to act on housing affordability is running into direct conflict with a series of market and fiscal headwinds. Unpacking these headwinds is essential to understanding what is doable in the near term.

Three headwinds are paramount.

First, the U.S. is paying dearly for federal fiscal irresponsibility. The annual budget deficit at the federal level now exceeds $2 trillion. The last time the deficit topped $2 trillion was in 2021 when COVID prompted Congress to pass an enormous stimulus package. Now the shortfall stems from increased spending on the military, interest payments on the debt and Social Security benefits, coupled with falling corporate tax receipts because of the 2025 tax cut package.

This is not a rocket science. America’s surging debt load, along with stubborn inflation, have driven up borrowing costs. Treasury bond yields, which influence interest rates for mortgages, credit cards and auto loans, hit their highest levels in two decades in early October before easing. Borrowing costs for companies and cities (and state and local governments) have also increased. The cumulative deficit has now topped a disturbing $40 trillion.

Second, the war with Iran has had devastating inflationary effects. The closure of the Strait of Hormuz, through which 20 percent of the world’s global petroleum flows, led to a spike in gas prices. This had a predictable ripple effect on the price of everything — from the cost of daily commutes to the price of goods at grocery stores to the cost of building materials, given increased manufacturing and shipping expenses for building materials.

The average gallon of gasoline now costs approximately $3.80 per gallon nationally, roughly $0.75 higher than last year. (That would be a bargain in major metropolitan areas like Los Angeles, where the average price for a gallon of regular gas tops $5.50). Diesel prices are significantly higher than the levels seen a year ago.

An analysis released by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York shows that lower-income Americans, those earning less than $40,000 a year, have been hit hardest by rising gas prices. These are the same households that are often compelled to live at the periphery of metropolitan housing markets, trading savings on rents for long commutes.

The final headwind involves municipal finance. The fiscal conditions of cities (and some states) face tough sledding in the next several years. The National League of Cities issues an annual fiscal conditions report, interpreting data from more than 250 cities. Their latest report in November of 2025, found that only 45% of city finance officers felt optimistic about meeting fiscal needs in FY2026, down from 64% in 2024.

Meanwhile, research by the Pew Charitable Trusts found that fiscal conditions in multiple cities are worsening for many reasons. On one hand, federal government actions are negatively affecting economic activity and fiscal health. Federal pandemic aid, which amounted to tens of billions of dollars, has been largely spent. The Trump Administration has successfully scaled back funding for certain government investments which affect cities disproportionately either because they undermine the critical “eds and meds” sector (e.g., cuts in Medicaid and scientific medical research) or provide income supplements and other assistance to low-income residents (e.g., SNAP). Uncertainty about appropriations for and federal stewardship of a host of other programs, ranging from housing and education to disaster relief and small business, create further economic and fiscal challenges for cities.

But there are market reasons as well. Cities are facing the long tail of the pandemic and the accelerated shift to remote work. That means fewer people in the office and fewer feet on downtown streets, lowering municipal tax revenues across multiple dimensions.

The ability of cities to adapt to fiscal challenges has been severely hampered by decades of state legislation or referenda which tie their hands. The latest example is the enactment of Amendment 3 in Florida, which increased the homestead tax exemptions for non-school district property taxes from $25,000 to $150,000 in 2026 and $250,000 in 2028 and restricted the services that could receive property tax revenues. Florida TaxWatch estimated that the measure could reduce local government revenue by $4.9 billion in its first fiscal year and by $45.8 billion over five years. Florida, in other words, is a reckless experiment in fiscal malpractice.

States are facing their own fiscal challenges. As Josh Goodman has found[3]:

“In October 2026, states will begin paying a larger share of the administrative costs for the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), formerly known as food stamps. From fiscal 2028 to fiscal 2030, many states may have to begin paying a share of SNAP benefits for the first time in the program’s history. But when, whether, and how much they pay will depend on their SNAP error rates.
…
Similarly, starting at the end of 2026, states must implement Medicaid work requirements and more frequent checks of enrollee eligibility — responsibilities that also carry substantial administrative costs. Further, from fiscal 2028 through fiscal 2032, the federal law will impose increasingly stringent limits on state taxes on health care providers — a primary source of state Medicaid funding.

Together, these provisions mean that some states will face new spending obligations or revenue restrictions in each of the next six years, with eventual annual impacts in the tens of billions of dollars, collectively.”

The last piece of the puzzle involves the operations of the federal government. The recent election results make Trump a lame duck. The history of lame duck presidencies in the modern era generally means increased oversight of the sitting Administration. Think about Democratic rule in the House and Senate during the last two years of the Reagan Presidency. The Iran-Contra hearings. The uncovering of abuses at HUD.

But oversight doesn’t need to be coupled with legislative paralysis. The past two years of the Reagan Administration also exhibited a recommitment to housing progress through the enactment of the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act of 1987 and the Housing and Community Development Act of 1987.

What does this mean for today?

As Ed Luce recently opined[4], there is no doubt that “Democrats [will tie the Trump Administration] up in investigations and subpoenas. His remaining agenda, such as it is, would also be dead on arrival.”

But, unlike the Reagan presidency, the potential for federal legislative progress, particularly with the appointment of Steven Miller as White House Chief of Staff, appears slim. As Chris Christie recently observed: “Trump is more likely to turn into an angry duck. My fear is not of specific things he will do … but of the great Trumpian unknown.”

In other words, buckle up, it’s going to be a bumpy ride.

Reconciling Tailwinds, Headwinds and an Angry Lame Duck

In sum, the political tailwinds behind addressing the affordability crisis are substantial, cutting across all regions and levels of government. But these tailwinds are running directly into a series of market and fiscal headwinds (which are structural and not conducive to quick change) and a lame duck who is unlikely to compromise.

So, what does this mean?

The room for maneuverability at the federal level is narrow. Introducing large spending bills will be cathartic, but they are unlikely to get signed. Large scale appropriations, without tax offsets, will trigger more panic in the bond markets and a rebuke by the Federal Reserve.

There is a slight chance that Congress could pass (and the president would sign) a bill that is revenue neutral or revenue minimal. This could build on the federal government’s credit and tax platform and involve, for example, the enactment of low-cost FHA debt products for starter homes or workforce housing or reforms to unlock TIFIA and RRIF loans for homes near transit.

For the most part, however, the next two years will see the continued flourishing of state and local action, albeit bounded and constrained by the fiscal challenges described above. This action could boost housing supply, lower housing costs and enhance preservation via several avenues.

Deregulation

An increasing number of states and cities could advance deregulatory initiatives by allowing more types of housing to be built in more places, setting goals for how to get there, and making the process of building (and renovation) less burdensome.

This could build upon efforts in many states that have developed planning regimes to encourage or require local governments to zone for a certain amount of housing. This could also extend the efforts at the local level to legalize Accessory Dwelling Units, along with duplexes, triplexes and even fourplexes, on single family lots and speed up permitting processes and other regulatory reviews.

Capital Investment

A growing number of states and localities could couple land use and administrative reforms with the enactment of new, flexible capital sources, either to meet challenges that are outside the bounds of rigid federal programs or where federal funding is woefully insufficient given local demand.

This also would build on a rising tide of capital expansion at the state and local level. Consider the following:

  • Earlier this month, California voters approved an $11.25 billion bond measure to fund the construction of affordable housing, including both rental and homeownership housing as well as housing for veterans.
  • In April 2026, New York City Comptroller Mark Levine rolled out a $4 billion plan to use public pensions to speed up the construction of new homes and shore up subsidized buildings at risk, while safeguarding pension returns.
  • In 2025, Philadelphia approved $800 million in bonds for the H.O.M.E. initiative, with goals of both financing the building of new homes and preserving existing ones.
  • In 2024, Los Angeles County voters approved Measure A, a permanent half-cent sales tax expected to generate more than $1 billion per year to combat homelessness and expand the production and preservation of affordable housing
  • A growing number of states and local governments are creating revolving loan funds to catalyze middle-income and mixed-income development. Notable examples include Montgomery County, Maryland, Chattanooga, Chicago, and Atlanta.

Beyond raising their own capital, state and local governments are also likely to continue engaging with philanthropy to unlock civic commitments. Local housing accelerator funds, or other commitments of concessionary public and/or philanthropic capital, have proliferated in the last several years in Atlanta, Boston, Chattanooga, Cleveland and San Francisco. All in all, well over $700M of concessionary state, local, and philanthropic capital has been committed to solve local housing crises in recent years.

Governance Reforms

The next two years will also likely see a rise in governance reforms.

One popular (and highly replicable) reform seeks to reduce fragmentation and coordinate activities within state and local governments. Atlanta Mayor Dickens led the way on this with the creation of a Housing Strike Force to force local agencies that deliver or touch housing — public housing authorities, school districts, transportation agencies and other governmental entities — to work together on general policy shifts and the delivery of specific projects. New Jersey Governor Mikie Sherrill has smartly adapted this to state government with the establishment of a multi-agency Housing Governing Council.

Another popular reform involves using publicly owned land and buildings to spur the production of affordable and attainable housing. In some cases, existing housing agencies are acting as master developers of large districts previously used for alternative purposes. New York State, for example, is converting former correctional facilities and psychiatric institutions for large-scale housing developments.

In other cases, new public asset corporations are being created, explicitly modeled after European successes. In 2023, Atlanta created the Atlanta Urban Development Corporation (AUD) to drive efforts to develop underutilized land across the city, with power to implement a tax exemption for qualifying projects.

Finally, communities are experimenting with new forms of metropolitan governance to better align housing interventions with the natural geography of housing markets. The Los Angeles County referendum mentioned above provides resources for a new system of housing governance in a county with ten million residents spread across eighty-eight cities. In Columbus, Ohio, a multi-sectoral Regional Housing Coalition aims to support the housing effort of the region’s 16 cities, 18 townships, nine villages, and dozens of civic and private sector entities—offering technical assistance on zoning and permitting, centralized market data, and coordinated policy advocacy.

The bottom line is this. There is a tight window for federal action over the next two years. As Hawaii Senator Brian Schatz observed before the elections: “While Trump is still president, we’re not going to pass visionary progressive legislation. If you give us power, we will in some cases reverse his decisions, stop him from making terrible decisions and in other cases slow him down.”[5]

By contrast, there is ample potential for meaningful action, across partisan lines, at the state and local levels. This is partly because the diffusion of state and local innovation is a hallmark of our federalist system. But it’s also because foundations like Bloomberg Philanthropies are putting serious resources and energy beyond the spreading of proven solutions. As I’ve recently written, they have committed funding to spread Atlanta’s Strike Force model, Austin’s ADU reforms and San Diego’s speedy permitting to 30 other cities, with roughly ten local governments deploying each of these solutions.

Federalist actions, in other words, are the path to reconciling political tailwinds, market headwinds and an angry lame duck. In many respects, the coming period of federalist innovation will rival if not surpass prior periods when governors led national efforts on education and welfare reform and mayors led national efforts on public safety and crime reduction. And, if history teaches us anything, state and local innovations today will form the basis of what candidates propose in the presidential election in 2028 and what Congress enacts in 2029.

Elections matter. At the federal level, it will restore the balance between the legislative and executive branches, with Congress once again playing its oversight role. But meaningful action on affordability? That is in the hands of state and local governments and our federalist system more broadly. Lets make the most of it.

 


[1] Alan Smith, Steven Bernard, Jonathan Vincent, Eva Kiao and Michael Taffe “Affordability and inflation shift voters to the left,” Financial Times, November 7/8, 2026
[2] https://ballotpedia.org/Party_affiliation_of_the_mayors_of_the_100_largest_cities
[3] Josh Goodman, Mounting Pressures Usher in a New Budget Era | The Pew Charitable Trusts, Pew January 12, 2026
>[4] Ed Luce, “Donald Trump’s Endgame, FT Magazine, October 31, 2026
[5] Annie Karni, “Here’s What Democrats Plan to Do with Their Power if They Win Back Congress,” New York Times, October 23, 2026


Bruce Katz is Founder of New Localism Associates and a Senior Advisor to the National Housing Crisis Task Force.


Older
by Bruce Katz and Sarah Karlinsky · November 12
Remaking Housing Federalism for a New Era